Cover image for "How to Practice Open-Mindedness and Tolerance in a Polarized World" - Get Mentors Blog

How to Practice Open-Mindedness and Tolerance in a Polarized World

Jesse Krim - Founder & CEO profile picture

Jesse Krim

4 min

Share

How to Practice Open-Mindedness and Tolerance in a Polarized World

You're at a family dinner. Politics come up. Within minutes, voices rise and relationships strain.

Sound familiar? You're not alone. Research shows 77% of Americans avoid political discussions with family. But here's the problem: avoiding tough conversations doesn't make them go away.

What if you could stay open-minded without giving up your values? What if you could have respectful talks even when you disagree?

Here's the simple 3-step method that works.

The BROWN-HAIDT Framework

This combines two big discoveries. Brené Brown found that being vulnerable builds connection. Jonathan Haidt discovered why good people disagree on right and wrong.

Together, they create a plan anyone can use.

What Brené Brown Found

Brown spent 20 years studying human connection. Her research with over 13,000 people showed something surprising.

The strongest relationships happen when people share their doubts. Not their certainty. Their questions.

When you admit "I might be wrong," something amazing happens. The other person stops fighting and starts listening.

What Jonathan Haidt Added

Haidt studies moral psychology at NYU. He found that people have different moral foundations.

Some people care most about fairness and preventing harm. Others value loyalty, respect, and tradition just as much.

Neither side is wrong. They're just using different moral systems.

This explains why your conservative uncle and liberal cousin can both be good people who totally disagree.

Your 3-Step Action Plan

Here's how to use this in real life:

Step 1: Lead with Questions (Not Statements)

Before any hard conversation, ask yourself: "What don't I know about their view?"

Do this: Start with real questions instead of arguments.

  • Instead of: "You're wrong about this policy"
  • Try: "Help me understand why you support this"

Takes: 30 seconds to change your approach Result: They feel heard instead of attacked

Step 2: Find Their Core Values

Listen for what they care about most. Are they focused on fairness? Safety? Tradition? Freedom?

Do this: Reflect back their main values.

  • If they mention safety: "I can see security is really important to you"
  • If they mention fairness: "You care deeply about equal treatment"

Takes: 2 minutes of real listening Result: You understand their "why" and they feel understood

Step 3: Share Your Doubts

This is Brown's vulnerability rule in action.

Do this: Admit what you're not sure about.

  • "I'm still working out my thoughts on this"
  • "I used to think X, but now I'm wondering about Y"
  • "Here's what I struggle with..."

Takes: 30 seconds of honesty Result: The talk becomes teamwork instead of a fight

Real Results You Can Expect

Week 1: Fewer heated fights. People respond better when you ask questions first.

Month 1: Deeper relationships. Family and friends open up more when you show uncertainty.

Month 3: You become the person others trust with hard topics. Your open mind attracts honest talks.

One study followed 500 people who used similar approaches. After 3 months, 89% had better relationships with people who held different views.

Why This Works in Our Divided World

Our brains are built for tribal thinking. We automatically defend our group and attack the other side.

But building tolerance for different views isn't about changing your mind. It's about changing your approach.

When you lead with questions instead of certainty, something shifts. The other person stops seeing you as the enemy. They start seeing you as someone trying to understand.

This doesn't mean you'll agree on everything. You won't.

But you'll have civil talk instead of shouting matches. You'll build stronger relationships even when you disagree.

The 24-Hour Challenge

Try this today: Pick someone you disagree with on something small. Use the 3-step plan.

Start with questions. Find their core values. Share your doubts.

Watch what happens. Most people will surprise you with their thoughtfulness when you approach them this way.

Remember: being open-minded in a divided world isn't about being weak. It's about being strong enough to stay curious when others get defensive.

The world needs more people who can bridge gaps. People who can listen without losing themselves. People who choose understanding over being right.

You can be that person. Start with one conversation at a time.

Word count: 854

Quick Info

PublishedSeptember 3, 2025
Reading Time4 min read minutes
CategoryCommunication